Had any bad experience with Lancaster Insurance?

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

MirrorSignalSwerve

New Member
Posts
111
Six days.. six whole days. Of all the woes I expected from owning a P.38, I couldn't have predicted this..

Clearly the former pride & joy of an old boy who has gone to a better place, I bought a pristine 1996 2.5 DSE off a funeral director with an entreprenurial streak who deals in cars of the recently departed as a side line. Full main dealer service history, 77k and not a mark on it. I was chuffed to find it and enjoyed six whole days of owning her until a chance meeting with an Italian sports car that drove on to my side of the road for some unexplained reason and buried itself in my rear axle. I went into a perfect 180 degree turn in time to see his wheel come off as he hit roadside railings. His car looked worse than mine, but it looks like I'm going to come out of this worse off. As nice a Rangie as you could fiind for the year it is, but I doubt it will make it through the engineers examination and be suitable for repair. Probably a CAT D total loss, but we'll see.

Anyway, counting my blessings that no-one was hurt and that it was only me in the car and not the kids, I thought I'd ring my insurers - Lancaster Insurance - to get some help. I wasn't expecting much on the Saturday (lunchtime) between Christmas and New Year, but there was an answer. Luckily I'd taken out fully comp insurance, so I was expecting a recovery truck to be dispatched to the scene and a courtesy car sent out within hours... how naive of me. The buck passing began straight away. 'We can't help you, but if you ring this number...' I'll spare the details, but after being passed round from department to department and repeating my story half a dozen times, I arranged my own recovery and went home on the back of an AA truck.

I rang the insurers again as I was now at home and had all my papers to hand. I gave all my details and the story of what had happened to a very pleasant lady and I was hopeful that the friendly voice at the other end of the phone was now going to get everything sorted for me. After I had answered all of her questions, I asked what would happen now. Well, nothing. She had everything she needed and I would have to ring my insurance company to make a claim. Me: 'But you are my insurance company'. Her: 'No, we're your brokers, its all down to your insurance company - Equity Red Star - to sort out your claim'. Me: 'What do you do then as my brokers?' Her: 'We just get you a cheap quote'. Me: ' Why have we been having this discussion for the last 10 minutes then? Why have you been asking me all my details an about how the accident happened?' Her: 'For our records'. Me: 'How is that going to help me?' Her: 'You'll have to ring your insurers, they'll help'. Anyway, you get the idea. I got bugger all help.

I tried the insurers, but it was Saturday afternoon. No chance. My damaged Rangie sat outside my house on the street all weekend.

I took the philosophical view that it was an awkward time of year to have an accident and got a cab to meet the wife & kids at the panto half way through.

Monday morning, I started again, Predictably, none of the details taken for their records on Saturday were known to anyone in the Lancaster office on Monday. I repeated the tale of woe and was then directed to the insurers to repeat it all again. This could go on forever, but I'll shorten this bit and summarise it as several calls to broker - passed from one individual to another, repeating the same info over again. Slightly fewer calls to insurer who didn't have my policy details as the broker has 'delegated responsibility so we allow certain companies to conduct the administration on our behalf'. It ended up with Lancaster passing the buck to Equity and Equity saying that Lancaster needed to sort this out - me in the middle becoming more Victor Meldrew with each fob off. One call to Lancaster resulted in me being deliberately dumped to a direct line back to Equity and another call meeting with the response that 'we can't help you, we're just a call centre'.

What rubbed salt in the wound was when I spoke to some people they said they would help, but they didn't. They were impatient and terse with me, when I'd have thought that was my entitlement! They'd give me a load of excuses as to why they couldn't do anything and then when I said that I was disappointed that I was having to do so much of the ringing round myself, they would get quite cross and tell me how busy they were. I can just imagine the conversation in the office when I ended the call - a discussion on how rude I was. I honestly wasn't rude - just disappointed, but polite with it. Trouble is, they weren't focused on the customer, they were busy with being busy and had no idea or understanding of how I experienced their handling of my claim. They knew best and were argumentative. What they didn't seem to apreciate is that I'd had 5 different people telling me 5 different things from the same company. When I explained that I'd just been told something in a previous call, I would be told that I was wrong and that the facts were X not Y. I was wrong? No, it was your colleague who told me that, I'm just repeating what they told me. Frustration compounded by poor attitude.

I think the final straw was the courtesy car issue. Don't get me wrong - there's lots of suffering in the world and me not getting some transport is a pain in the arse but it's not the end of the world. The outsourced courtesy car scheme that Lancaster referred me to said they wouldn't give me a car because someone veering onto my side of the road and hitting me wasn't a straightforward issue and that as liability wasn't clear, they wouldn't risk giving me a car as I might end up with the bill. Only thinking of me, apparently.

The insurers - Equity - will only provide a courtesy car if the car is being repaired at an approved centre. As mine looks like its going to be written off, I don't qualify. I can understand the logic in this, but it doesn't help ad I'm not sure what I pay a fully comp premium for.

Also, as its this time of year, a decision on the fate of my Rangie is unlikely until next week. If I knew one way or the other, I could sort out a stop gap car to get the family around for a while. As it is, we're in limbo. All involved in insuring my car have given their excuses and washed their hands of me.

I'm ****ed off.

There, I just needed to vent my frustration. Thanks for reading if you've got this far. I expect no sympathy, a fair mount of **** taking and perhaps the thoughts from one or two fellow victims who have had similar experiences.

Anyway, Happy New Year to all.
 
Cheers, just had a look at their website, thanks to the helpful link. The company who refused were carcrashline.co.uk and I thought they might be the same people trading under different names, but it seems not. There is an option with Helphire to take out a £10 policy to cover the costs of the courtesy car in case liability can't be proved. I'll ring them in the morning. Thanks again Ratty.
 
Can't say I'm inspired or surprised. I think I'm half expecting the hassle and negotiations about a payout. However, I'll stick this out for as long as I can, especially as I'd only bought it six days earlier. I'm also collecting adverts of similar year/spec Rangies so that I can show them mine was a fair price.

The payout ****about is fully anticipated. What has made me grumpy is the lack of service from Lancaster and Equity at the initial stages of the claim. They couldn't even get my car recovered - it was completely undriveable and in the middle of the road. I'm glad I was in the AA and got them to pick it up. Then the patronising carcrashline service, giving me a load of tosh about liability and that they were only thinking about me and how it might land me with a huge bill. Bollocks they were thinking of me.

I think the Co-Op do insurance and I'll go with them in future even if they're not the cheapest. I've always heard good things about them and the true test of value for money from an insurance policy is how they respond to a claim.

Pleased to hear you got a result... eventually. Here's to a couple of months of being messed around then!
 
I would give helphire a ring. They specialise in accidents that aren't your fault. It will cost you a small 'administration charge' (about £20). They will provide you with a courtesy car at the other persons expense and get you back any out of pocket costs incurred.

Helphire Group plc - Helphire Group plc

We used these as we had arranged their courtesy car cover through our broker (Adrian Flux) when we had our prang, like for like car....ended up with a VW Toureg 3lt V6 TD all bells and whistles (120mph and still accelerating, company driver driving not us)!! Pretty good considering we had a 300TDi Disco:D.

Wife got jittery and they swapped it for a Zafira:wtf:(she regrets that now:frusty:). All in all, had hire car for 12 weeks and got a courtesy call from them every few days.

Can highly recommend them (take out the extra insurance...covers any damage to hire car), and their legal team are spot on too.

Our neighbour who trashed our Disco ingnored us for ages after helphire had finished with her ins. co. and bumped up her policy cost.:D:D:D
 
The missus and me both use direct line. They've been aroundthe cheapest and when the missus wrote off her nearly new car they sorted everything out pronto and without any hassle at all.
 
doesn't seem to be any middle ground. I use LV, and they were really helpful when my old astravan slid into the back of a laguna on the M25, couldn't do enough for me. I had the van recovered to my house that night so I could unload. They came the next day to pick it (and me) up to take me to the repairing garage, where I got my courtesy car.

The garage did question whether I really needed the courtesy car, but when it went back with over 2000 extra miles on it, they got the point !

3 weeks later, drove back to the garage, picked up my van and left the courtesy car.

They are a bit more expensive on their quotes, but I guess that's what you pay for.

The issue with having to use their "approved repairer" is neither here nor there. As long as it is repaired to an acceptable standard, it doesn't matter to me who does it. If they want you to use their repairer, so be it. Whenever I drop any vehicle to a garage or repairer, I always make a point of going back in and asking for the keys 5 minutes after handing them over, saying "I need to record the mileage for our vehicle logs". Then they know that you have the mileage written down, and hopefully it won't come back with any extra miles on it.
 
It was a wonderful six days, but its all over. The engineer looked at the car tody and declared it a total loss. Not even worth me buying the salvage and arranging my own repairs. Ah well, no-one was hurt, so that's a comfort. Also, the engineer was helpful, comfortably valuing the car at what I'd paid for it a few days before the accident. We'll see what merry dance the underwriters try to lead me through.

Helphire weren't as efficient as I'd hoped. They took details a couple of days ago and promised me a hire car today, but it didn't show up. My initial enquiries on the phone were of the usual excuses type, but I was fed up so I cancelled. I'm looking at a 4.6HSE with an LPG conversion tomorrow. Looks promising, so I could be back on the road. Just waiting for my current insurers to quote me for cover. I'll change companies when the policy is up for renewal, but in the meantime, with an unsettled accident claim pending I think they are the only option unless I shell out large.

I also got hold of a jump seat for the boot. Anyone managed to get insurance for this modification?
 
They'll change my car over on the current policy for a £15 fee, which is reasonable. Only trouble is a hefty £600 excess. Guess I'm stuck with this until the claim is sorted and/or policy comes up for renewal. I think I'm going to buy the 4.6 HSE.
 
Well, I bought the 4.6 HSE today and I'm regretting it already. Its not as nice as the one written off this week, although I'm probably comparing a well used car with an old boys pride and joy. Its clear to me now what a bargain I had in the DSE.

The HSE seemed OK mechanically. I went through the checks I promised myself I'd do, having read the advice on this site. No wet carpets. No oil in the water or vice versa. Air suspension up & down OK. etc etc.

The seller had no LPG in it, so having haggled him down on some of the cosmetics, I thought I'd got a good deal. The journey home was about 80 miles and on petrol it goes really well. I put some LPG in it and switched over and its a pig. I switched back to petrol and all is fine. Fook.

I've been reading up on-line this evening and am starting to think about the cooling system. It seemed Ok on inspection and boasts a new rad fitted by a LR garage in November. However, the heater isn't belting out much heat, so its got me thinking. I'll have the bonnet up in the morning and take a look when I have some light to work with. I have a sneaking feeling that the expansion tank was empty, but I couldn't see well enough in the dark and came over a bit depressed so put it all to bed for the night.

Fook.
 
When I had a smash I got some help from a trader in the family who does accident repair/recovery etc. In your shoes I would consider spiking the lazy insurer as per the following.......

If your insurer writes it off as a total loss, write them a letter (sent recorded) saying when they have paid out the loss and the chrque has cleared you will recover the vehicle (they have no right to keep it). Ask them to provide location and a contact.

Hook up with a friendly local garage with recovery and storage facilities and recover it from their pound to yours (his) and then either auction it to the repair trade on bluecycle.com or similar or if too much hassle break the simple and high value bits (alloys/leather etc) onto ebay and sell to scrap on the rest.

You should be able to make a good chunk of any losses back this way.
Be careful to do it quick as when they get wind they'll (insurer) will charge you daily storage in their pound.

On this last point you might consider recovering it now and charging them a daily storage rate - its amazing how much quicker your claim goes through :D
 
When I had a smash I got some help from a trader in the family who does accident repair/recovery etc. In your shoes I would consider spiking the lazy insurer as per the following.......

If your insurer writes it off as a total loss, write them a letter (sent recorded) saying when they have paid out the loss and the chrque has cleared you will recover the vehicle (they have no right to keep it). Ask them to provide location and a contact.

Hook up with a friendly local garage with recovery and storage facilities and recover it from their pound to yours (his) and then either auction it to the repair trade on bluecycle.com or similar or if too much hassle break the simple and high value bits (alloys/leather etc) onto ebay and sell to scrap on the rest.

You should be able to make a good chunk of any losses back this way.
Be careful to do it quick as when they get wind they'll (insurer) will charge you daily storage in their pound.

On this last point you might consider recovering it now and charging them a daily storage rate - its amazing how much quicker your claim goes through :D


I thought they owned it once they pay out? Isn't it normally the case that you have to buy the salvage back or take a reduced payout?
 
Back
Top