p38 2.5 diesel oil filter failure ruins engine.

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
R

roddy4

New Member
Posts
664
Location
banbury,oxfordshire
oil filter i purchased from a motor factor failed,engine now is noisy,replaced filter,and all is not well,where do i stand on this part failure,is it tough luck or does the supplier get the bill?
engine is noisy not as refined as it was,and has an unsteady idle.
info required.
taking it down to garage to check oil pressure.
 
A bit of a sticky wicket I'm affraid....

How can it be proved the filter did damage??

It would be a case of hear'say, without evidentual proof...i.e. fragments of filter found in engine causing dmage etc....

If you fitted it yourself, again another sticky one - they could argue - are you trained to fit oil filters, was it carried out in accordance with manufacuturers specifications and reccomendations, what tests and precautions were carried out...etc etc....

If a garage had fitted it, you would have some form of recourse to the garage or manufacturer as they have a duty of care to fit the product correctly and a duty of care to supply a product, that when fitted correctly to their spec and guidelines will not fail....

If you fitted it, and without evidentual proof it was the oil filter....your stuck me thinks....I am not a lawyer/barrister or solicitor....if you think you have a good case, consult the Citizens Advice Bureau in your area, and have a chat....its free.
 
.....to add:

If you still have the failed filter....you could consult the manufacturer and explain the issue...they might carryout an investigation on the filter and make a judgement on whether failure would result in your symptoms.....

If you don't have it....again sticky wicket as there is no item to investigate against...
 
Saint.V8 said:
A bit of a sticky wicket I'm affraid....

How can it be proved the filter did damage??

It would be a case of hear'say, without evidentual proof...i.e. fragments of filter found in engine causing dmage etc....

If you fitted it yourself, again another sticky one - they could argue - are you trained to fit oil filters, was it carried out in accordance with manufacuturers specifications and reccomendations, what tests and precautions were carried out...etc etc....

If a garage had fitted it, you would have some form of recourse to the garage or manufacturer as they have a duty of care to fit the product correctly and a duty of care to supply a product, that when fitted correctly to their spec and guidelines will not fail....

If you fitted it, and without evidentual proof it was the oil filter....your stuck me thinks....I am not a lawyer/barrister or solicitor....if you think you have a good case, consult the Citizens Advice Bureau in your area, and have a chat....its free.
Click to expand...

still have filter and the rubber seal on top of the paper cartridge that sits on the top ends the top one had dropped to the bottom, probably get nowhere as i fitted it myself.
 
roddy4 said:
still have filter and the rubber seal on top of the paper cartridge that sits on the top ends the top one had dropped to the bottom, probably get nowhere as i fitted it myself.
Click to expand...
I would still call the CAB and have a chat with someone there...you never know your luck....or they may give you a few numbers to call or who else you could chat too i.e. consumer advice, Office of Fair Trading etc...yer never know till yer try...
 
Saint.V8 said:
I would still call the CAB and have a chat with someone there...you never know your luck....or they may give you a few numbers to call or who else you could chat too i.e. consumer advice, Office of Fair Trading etc...yer never know till yer try...
Click to expand...

thankyou saint nothing to lose and maybe a bit to gain.
 
Crock of **** thread in general section has all you need.

Satisfactory quality and fit for purpose
 
roddy4 said:
cheers fanatic obviously was not!
however could take forever to get any kind of action.
Click to expand...

Consumer Direct first, they will possibly say write a letter and send recorded delivery and go from there.
 
Datatek said:
I suppose it was the right filter for the year? There are 2 different types.
Click to expand...
yep there are 2 types one for a plastic filter housing,and one for alloy mine is the alloy make of filter is wl 7043? i have receipt for filter and filter but no box,could buy another just for the box if need be.
 
fanatic said:
what make filter and how many miles on engine?
Click to expand...

engine has done 126,000 miles that could be against,but on start up after changing oil and filter,top end was rattly and sounded louder than usual mainly from cold,put in some valve treatment oil which quietened the top end down,but it just did not seem right,so i checked the oil filter and found that to be at fault.
so i may just be lucky and have just had low oil pressure?
or more serious will suffer bottom end failure?
only drove it 12 miles.
 
story so far,have been in touch with supplier,they have started to build a wall up,obviously they are not just going to rollover,the mileage is high? saying the filter with that fault would not damage the engine,it would give it a lower oil pressure still allowing oil circulation, they have offered a refund for the filter which i have declined,also offered a replacement which i too declined.
don't know what harm it has done will have to wait and see only drove 12 miles but at what oil pressure?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Jake Hewitt
For Sale 2000 P38 Auto 2.5 DSE Oil Cooler
Replies
0
Views
463
Jake Hewitt
Jake Hewitt
B
P38A P38 2.5 dse engine noise?
6 7 8
Replies
159
Views
12K
jimmacD
jimmacD
M
2010 Range Rover Sport TDV8 - Oil / Diesel Leak Around Injector?
Replies
17
Views
2K
rover75lover
rover75lover
MikeFl4
P38A M51 Diesel - Lumpy idle after rev - Setting the top section of the pump?
Replies
4
Views
1K
Datatek
Datatek
MikeFl4
P38A M51 Diesel – Its just not running right!! (video explanation for ease)
Replies
15
Views
2K
Datatek
Datatek
Back
Top