ZF 5HP24 Gearbox Oil Drain and Findings....is it Good News or Bad??

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

Saint.V8

Dyed-in-the-wool 100% RR Junkie
Full Member
Follow on from http://www.landyzone.co.uk/lz/f10/much-lamented-l322-zf-gearboxes-210367.html

So Saturday morning and time to drain the ATF and see what is going on in the ‘box....

First things first....

Tools required:
8mm Allen key for Sump and Fill/Level plugs
T27 Torx bit for Sump bolts and Filter Bolts
Pliers
Stanley Blade/Gasket Scrapper/Wide Screwdriver
Plenty of Rags
Drip Tray
Receptacle for Oil
Method of refilling (I used a pressure sprayer attached to a length of flexible hose)
Degreaser/cleaning products
SAFETY GLASSES

Always use the correct grade of ATF for the L322 Gearboxes – considering the price of this stuff, shopping around helps.

I bought 7 litres from a local VW/Audi place as theirs was the cheapest I could get hold of in the time I had....£11.70 a litre with the VAT. LR was £14 odd plus the VAT so was about £16-17 ish a litre...

VW part number G-052-162-A2

Process:
Raise Vehicle – Now before everyone goes bandy, I know driving up 4 ramps is a no-no, but I needed access underneath for a larger than average person and also have the vehicle level to drain and refill the box.

GB1.jpg


Climb underneath and laugh at the ‘Filled for Life’ sticker.. :D

GB2.jpg


On first inspection underneath, it looks like there has been a fluid leak from the front corner of the sump

GB3.jpg


GB4.jpg


GB5.jpg


Hmmmm....

OK, now before you do anything there are couple of Must Do steps

Spray some penetrating fluid on to the sump bolts, drain and fill plugs

GB6.jpg


Make sure you have a viable and working method of refilling the box, I used a cheap pressure Fence Sprayer from Homebase (£14.99) and took the little plastic filter off the end of the delivery tube, cut the yellow plastic tube shorter and attached some flexible hose to that so I could feed it into the fill hole.

GB7.jpg


GB8.jpg


Now this probably the most important part – make sure you can undo the fill level plug BEFORE you drain the oil out, I cannot stress this enough – if you can’t get it back in – you’re fecked !!!!

I was quite shocked just how tight the fill/level plug was – I am a rather large lad, and it took both hands pushing hard on a long Allen key to budge it....

GB10.jpg


Crack open but don’t drain the Sump Plug

GB11.jpg


Now go round the 22 Torx bits on the sump and only crack them open, don’t undo just a tweak....

On the side of the Sump is a metal plate covering the Selector switch...the official procedure is to remove this, but looking at it, and knowing the hassle caused if the selector isn’t set properly, you can just bend the side tabs back to allow the sump to be dropped.

GB16.jpg


Position your Oil Receptacle under the sump plug, remember the sump can contain 4.5 to 5 litres (sometimes up to 5.5 if not more litres)

GB12.jpg


You can now undo the drain plug....

GB14.jpg


GB13.jpg


The residual oil on my plug doesn’t look to bad!! Nor did the stuff coming out of the sump!!

The odd thing was I could only get about 3.5 litres out of the sump.....I have read and re-read articles and posts on the internet and I am sure I should have got more out of it – is this a sign??

GB15.jpg


Now, never having taken a Gearbox sump off before, I don’t know a) how heavy it is or b) how much oil is left that couldn’t be drained....so I used my large Trolley jacl set just below the pan, and started to undo the 22 torx bolts....count them off so you can count them on....!!!

GB18.jpg


GB19.jpg


I had about half a litre left in the sump when it was removed, so be carefull when removing it, and remember part of the sump sits above the gearbox protection cage, so you’ll have to wiggle it past that....

At first look, the oil looks clean to my untrained eye....slight tan colour to it, doesn’t smell burnt, still has the typical LT71141 fishy/odd smell to it, no sludge, no fillings, no glitter, no swarf, no bits, no grit, nothing....just oil!! Took a bit out and smeared it on white paper, no suspended debris, no odd colour, no blackness....just a tan/brown oil!!

GB20.jpg


GB21.jpg


The magnets in the corners don’t look too full of fillings, according to a thread on rangerovers.net they usually and should look like that....infact the comparison photo they showed was worse than mine!

GB22.jpg


GB23.jpg


GB23A.jpg


GB23B.jpg


Ok, so looking at the sump pan, oil and magnets, nothing looks out of place and infact looks a damn sight better than I had expected.....

Attention turns to the filter....

GB24.jpg


It is held in by 2 T27 Torx bolts, undo these and then pull the filter from the valve block , a little tug to over come the O ring seal, and be prepared for a splodge of oil and further oil to catch....

GB25.jpg


Looking at the filter, there is again no sludge, no sign of metallic debris, no burnt smell, no swarf....just brown/tan coloured oil....

GB26.jpg


So, after draining the oil I can summise the following....

No Black sludge
No Metal Fillings
No Glitter suspended in the oil
No Swarf
No Gritty bits
No Burnt Smell

Now while I am not saying there is nothing wrong with the box, maybe I have caught the demise early, maybe I was imagining it, maybe it is low on oil causing reduced hydraulic pressure???

The oil and filter certainly don’t seem to carry all the usual signs of failure....hmmmmm.

Time to clean the old gasket off the box and sump....that bit was the part that took the longest....you really should take your time and ensure you get all the old gasket off to ensure a good sealing surface. I used a Stanley blade and a screw driver (be careful not to score the mating faces)

Anyhoot, time to put it all back together.....

New Filter, O Ring and Sump Gasket (Genuine Land Rover parts sourced from Hunters Land Rover in Guildford), place the O Ring over the opening on the top side of the filter

GB28.jpg


GB29.jpg


GB30.jpg


With a little push to overcome O Ring seal, place the filter on the valve block and do up the 2 Torx bolts

GB31.jpg


Clean the sump using a good degreaser, clean the magnets and fit the new gasket....I smeared a bit of fresh ATF onto the sump lip to hold the gasket in place during fitment...

GB32.jpg


Put the sump pan back on, I placed two opposing corner bolts in first and held it loosely while I put the other two corners in....then one by one fit the other 18 bolts....count them back on remember...

Make sure you have the gasket seated correctly as you put the bolts in...once you have them all in, start nipping them up in a cross pattern to ensure the pan sits square and not twisted....

For the awkward one above the Protection frame, I used a spring drive to get the bit onto the bolt head

GB33.jpg


Time to prep for the fill.....pour new fluid into the pressure sprayer.

GB9.jpg


Open up the Fill/level plug and place fill hose into hole...

GB35.jpg


Pump up the sprayer and start to fill......

GB34.jpg


The initial fill must be done with the engine off, the first fill will be about 4 litres or so to fill the sump to the fill level.

When you start to get a thin line from the filler hole, start the engine and with foot firmly on the brake, go from P through R to N then on to D pausing for 2-3 seconds in each to begin refilling the valves and oil galleries....

Go back to P in tha same fashion pausing in each...start the fill once again until you get a thin bead again, then again cycle the gears.....back to P.....wait for the Gearbox oil temp to reach around 40degC (measure using am IR thermostat or similar or those with money can use a diagnostic to monitor the GB temp)

When it is up to temp, keep filling until you get another thin line from the filler plug, and remove the fill hose and put the plug back in....DO NOT TURN THE ENGINE OFF UNTIL THE FILL PLUG IS BACK IN as the GB pump will stop and all the fluid in the cooler and Torque Converter will drain back to the sump and pour out of the fill plug again!!!

I managed to get all 7 litres in...!!!!!!

Clean up and grab a coffee....all done!

CONCLUSION and FINDINGS:

Well considering all I have read suggests I should get between 4.5 and almost 6 litres from the sump/ filter etc....(the GB takes 10.5 litres from dry, but you will have 4.5-5 or so left in the TQ) I only managed to drain at the very most 4.5 litres....

GB36.jpg


BUT I refilled with 7 litres, which, considering the condition of the oil, leads me to suspect that my issue was concerned with the fluid level dropping to a point where hydraulic pressure was reduced causing clutch slipping....

Now I am not a Automatic box specialist, but to me the oil drained looked good (for 10 years old), the magnets and pan where clean, no burnt smell, nor anything untoward....

After getting it off the ramps a quick 15 minute drive should no ill effects, and whilst a longer drive will be more conclusive, there was no judder at 25-30 and only a faint hint at 40ish, but I couldn't tell if it was GB related or road condition....

Will give it a few weeks and see what happens....

Anyone got any views on the state of the oil or pan at all??

Time taken was about 6 hours, and it was very messy! :D:D:D
 
Last edited:
I would say you have been lucky in the minimal debris found on the magnets

Drive vehicle around for about 500 mile and drain refill oil again (no need to change filter)

The 2nd refill will enable the "old" oil that remained in the TC to have been mixed with your new oil and so a 2nd refill will remove as much of the original "old" oil as possible

Now you in the mood I would also replace front and rear diff oil and not forgetting the transfer box oil
 
great result, deff down to low oil level, have you checked your oil cooler for leaks? the pipes have crappy pushfit connectors on and they leak as i found out by losing a good 3 lts in a couple of weeks
 
when you get the judder at 40, try slipping into sport mode to see if that cures it . my thoughts are the torque converter failing . if it is you need to catch it before it starts to break up and start dumping crap into the box. a good auto trans man will be able to monitor the lock up on a test drive to confirm. watch the rev counter as well when juddering to see if the engine speed is changing..
 
Rather than struggle to force an Allen key, place a ring spanner over the end to extend your lever. Physics. Saving knuckles since ∞.

The leak would've caused problems, 3-4 litres is running dry. That in itself might've caused some of your bother. I wouldn't spend your gearbox repair fund just yet.
 
Last edited:
I would say you have been lucky in the minimal debris found on the magnets

Drive vehicle around for about 500 mile and drain refill oil again (no need to change filter)

The 2nd refill will enable the "old" oil that remained in the TC to have been mixed with your new oil and so a 2nd refill will remove as much of the original "old" oil as possible

Now you in the mood I would also replace front and rear diff oil and not forgetting the transfer box oil
That is on the cards to be done....beginning of next month to drain the sump again and fill with fresh....as you suggest I should also do the Diffs and TB too.

Very nice write up saint. What did it cost you??

I need to do mine I think....
Filter, O Ring and Gasket from LR Dealer - £48
7 litres of VW sourced LT71141 equivalent @ £11.70 /litre - £81.90
Pressure Fence Spray Bottle from Homebase - £14.99

I'd say the oil looks tired but not that bad, the leak and lack of sparkly swarf suggests you may be a lucky boy!
The oil is 10 years old almost and as you say does look tired, but no contamination or metal fillings found - whilst I am not saying my problems are over....but I am hoping that the lack of the usual signs will be a good thing!

great result, deff down to low oil level, have you checked your oil cooler for leaks? the pipes have crappy pushfit connectors on and they leak as i found out by losing a good 3 lts in a couple of weeks
When I changed the Rad last month, the Oil Cooler looked fine, but I will check it on your advice....I am hoping my judder issue was down to low hydraulic pressure casuing the clutch plates to slip slightly....Will look under the bonnet in the morning.

when you get the judder at 40, try slipping into sport mode to see if that cures it . my thoughts are the torque converter failing . if it is you need to catch it before it starts to break up and start dumping crap into the box. a good auto trans man will be able to monitor the lock up on a test drive to confirm. watch the rev counter as well when juddering to see if the engine speed is changing..
Changing to Sport mode as far as I could tell didn't change the judder pattern or frequency.....also the LUC came in on time and held strong with no rev bouncing.....

If the LUC in the TC was on its way out to the point of juddering, I would have expected more evidence in the oil i.e. friction material traces etc....as my oil looked old, but clean and grit/sludge free, I am hoping on there being nothing mechanically wrong....well I can only hope..!!

I am under no impression I have fixed it, just going by the other usual symptomns and photos of a box on its way out - mine does look in reasonable fettle.....keep them fingers crossed!
 
Rather than struggle to force an Allen key, place a ring spanner over the end to extend your lever. Physics. Saving knuckles since ∞.

The leak would've caused problems, 3-4 litres is running dry. That in itself might've caused some of your bother. I wouldn't spend your gearbox repair fund just yet.
As you say Bix, the box has a capacity of 10.5litres from dry....I drained 4-4.5 litres and put 7 litres back in....so the box was low by about 2.5-3 litres which is between 25-33% of the total capacity....so I am hoping it was just down to the low fluid level.:eek:
 
That oil was expensive mate

You can get it at wholesale on the Internet

Landrover charge £12 a litre for the GM fluid

I got a 20 litre barrel on the Internet for £80

Perfect for flushing through ;)
 
As you say Bix, the box has a capacity of 10.5litres from dry....I drained 4-4.5 litres and put 7 litres back in....so the box was low by about 2.5-3 litres which is between 25-33% of the total capacity....so I am hoping it was just down to the low fluid level.:eek:
I imagine the localised heat build up could've caused some bother. Since the temp sensor is based on ATF heat, if you're running low it is possible parts of your box were overheating while the fluid still remained in the safe temp range. You wouldn't know unless you can get a butchers inside, but I wouldn't be surprised if you have various blue bits in there now.
 
That oil was expensive mate

You can get it at wholesale on the Internet

Landrover charge £12 a litre for the GM fluid

I got a 20 litre barrel on the Internet for £80

Perfect for flushing through ;)
Very true - I did see one place that would do a 20L drum for £138....but the time to deliver would have meant the vehicle being off the road for longer and whilst I have an understanding boss, his generosity of borrowing one of the Defenders for a few days would only last so long!
 
Great write up Ant.

That tree in the sump would have been soaking oil up :p
Cheers Stu....

The Girlfriend noticed that too....have to say when I first looked at the photo when I D/L'ed on to the comp this evening, I did have to do a double take to see what it was...then the girlfriend hit me on the back of the head and said 'it's a reflection of the tree you prat!':eek:
 
As others have said, the oil looks a bit tired but otherwise OK, let's hope you are lucky. Sealed for life means until the box breaks. I would say change the oil every 20 to 30K miles depending on how hard a life it has.
Good write up and photo's.
 
Yep looks like oil could of needed changing sooner . As for driving up four ramps you didn't need to , with a decent trolley jack you could drive on the first two and jack the car up On Axels and slide the remaining two under .
 
cant beat the drive on ramps. much safer if there proper strong ones....

takes 5 mins, no jacks, no axel stands :)

these were custom made ones

IMG_0367.jpg
 
cant beat the drive on ramps. much safer if there proper strong ones....

takes 5 mins, no jacks, no axel stands :)

these were custom made ones

IMG_0367.jpg

What them tiny things lol I'm talking proper ramp that if they were to slip and caus damage time over money doesn't equate IMO
 
Staint.

It looks to me you may have been lucky. A slow leak from the sump eventually getting to 'terminal' oil level.. You picking it up immediately and reacting.

I would look to draing and flush to get as much new oil in as possible.
So these are designed never to have an oil change? Madness!!

Is there no way of cheaking the oil level? No level alarm?

Lastly, I haven't looked but there you can surely get a one shot oil test kit off the net. that could be interesting.

Oil simply does not last for ever!!

Hope you have been lucky..

Best wishes.
 
Back
Top