Brand new Defender

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

waldershelf

Well-Known Member
No I haven't bought one but I was in the dealer in Sheffield (Guy Salmon) picking up some parts for a S3 disco.
I went into the showroom and had a look at a new 2.2L 90" Defender, electric windows, leather seats, air con, central locking etc etc. In fact all the toys you find on a "modern" car. BUT................

Sat in the drivers seat I could see daylight through the lower front corner of the passenger door just like on my old 'un.
Along with all the other ill fitting, poorly designed,"features" we all love about our 'fenders.

And sure enough when I looked underneath, absolutely no protective coating on the chassis at all, just chassis black which was starting to show rust on a 0 miles vehicle.

And this costs over £30 grand.

There is really no surprise that Land Rover can't sell them in profitable numbers any more.

Much as I love my old banger I have to say no one in their right mind would by a new one.

Come on Land Rover it's time for a new Defender, and not the plastic fantastic "concepts" we have seen so far.

So what do you think? what does the new defender need to be?:-

I'll start.

Ladder chassis, so utility companies and the forces can have all sorts of cranes, cherry pickers, fire engines etc etc. and we can have the robustness for off roading.

Coil sprung, mechanical dampers, straight forward simple engineering for utility, strength and axle articulation, not road holding and finesse.

Similar look to the existing model but manufactured using modern techniques and materials. So it's properly built like a modern car not a throwback to the 1950's

And lets have some cabin ergonomics, with seats and a driving position that fit normal size people, a bit more right arm room, forward and backward seat movement and a handbrake lever that doesn't stick in the drivers leg would be nice.

A full range of body styles and options built on a modular concept to maximise the flexibility/options available to satisfy as many specialist customers as possible.

Lastly for me, price, make it competitive with other vehicles in its sector.
 
if all that happens i can see the billboard adverts now

" designed on a computer ....built by robots.....driven by a loonatic " :D:D:D:D
 
I agree with what you have said, but the problem is that what you have described is a normal defender, but built slightly better with a different body on it, which I suppose froma landrover business view would be silly, how ever, they could do this and sell it as a utility vhercal (maybe this would help to pass emissions regulations) and then also do a landrover that more people can afford as at 30k for a new one or 10k for one that's a couple years old and the same, not many people will be wanting to go brand new so I was thinking they could make something in the 15-25k mark where more people can afford them and therefore more sales, but also if landrover read this, I beg you DO NOT MAKE SOME SHIITY SOFT ROADER that cannot be used off road apart from a dry flat field
 
its just wrong on so many levels. my old un has aircon(flaps on front and ill fitting panels) heated seats (transmission tunnel getting warm) i had a series with cruise control (PTO throttle). mate of mine bought a brand new one a few years ago and the clutch failed after 26000 miles. the sales manager tried to fob hin off saying it was his bad driving so he went home got a flip chart and a load of manuals and went back to give him a debrief on how clutches work ( he's a mechanical engineer in the REME) needless to say they surrended and did his clutch
 
No I haven't bought one but I was in the dealer in Sheffield (Guy Salmon) picking up some parts for a S3 disco.
I went into the showroom and had a look at a new 2.2L 90" Defender, electric windows, leather seats, air con, central locking etc etc. In fact all the toys you find on a "modern" car. BUT................

Sat in the drivers seat I could see daylight through the lower front corner of the passenger door just like on my old 'un.
Along with all the other ill fitting, poorly designed,"features" we all love about our 'fenders.

And sure enough when I looked underneath, absolutely no protective coating on the chassis at all, just chassis black which was starting to show rust on a 0 miles vehicle.

And this costs over £30 grand.

There is really no surprise that Land Rover can't sell them in profitable numbers any more.

Much as I love my old banger I have to say no one in their right mind would by a new one.

Come on Land Rover it's time for a new Defender, and not the plastic fantastic "concepts" we have seen so far.

So what do you think? what does the new defender need to be?:-

I'll start.

Ladder chassis, so utility companies and the forces can have all sorts of cranes, cherry pickers, fire engines etc etc. and we can have the robustness for off roading.

Coil sprung, mechanical dampers, straight forward simple engineering for utility, strength and axle articulation, not road holding and finesse.

Similar look to the existing model but manufactured using modern techniques and materials. So it's properly built like a modern car not a throwback to the 1950's

And lets have some cabin ergonomics, with seats and a driving position that fit normal size people, a bit more right arm room, forward and backward seat movement and a handbrake lever that doesn't stick in the drivers leg would be nice.

A full range of body styles and options built on a modular concept to maximise the flexibility/options available to satisfy as many specialist customers as possible.

Lastly for me, price, make it competitive with other vehicles in its sector.
I followed one such vehicle down the A1 tonight...it had a Toyota badge on the tailgate.:rolleyes:
 
what you have described is a normal defender, but built slightly better with a different body on it,

I think that sort of sums it up. Land Rover need to build a proper defender, a utility vehicle, abandon all pretence it is anything else and make it do what it does best.
We have Freelanders, Disco's, Range Rovers and even the awful Evoke for the luxury, lifestyle, SUV, mom on the school run market niche's.

So get rid of all the nonesense and build us a proper modern Defender. We know land Rover has the technology and the financial clout to do it, all they need is the will.
 
My 90 has no ill-fitting panels, I'm snug as a bug in a rug... And if I could afford it (money no object) I would definitely DEFINITELY buy a brand new one.

But if they HAVE to update the defender :)p) then I guess I kind of agree... The only thing I would add is that Land Rover has to STOP compromising function for form... When you start doing things like keeping the spare wheel under the fuel tank so that it doesn't dirty up the look of the new Discos then you stop having a Land Rover and start having a handbag.
 
My 90 has no ill-fitting panels, I'm snug as a bug in a rug... And if I could afford it (money no object) I would definitely DEFINITELY buy a brand new one.

But if they HAVE to update the defender :)p) then I guess I kind of agree... The only thing I would add is that Land Rover has to STOP compromising function for form... When you start doing things like keeping the spare wheel under the fuel tank so that it doesn't dirty up the look of the new Discos then you stop having a Land Rover and start having a handbag.

Well, I agree with you. Our new baby is as snug as a bug in a rug. The Landy (brand new) that we played with on the Land Rover Experience day was also top hole.

Esm xx
 
The Land Rover Defender is to the car world what the AK47 is to the firearms world:

crude, rugged, built to loose tolerances, obsolete, utilitarian, capable of functioning anywhere and a ****ing icon.

It simply is what it is - 2012 or 1948 reg. You either love it or you hate it. That's it. Job done.
 
yeah you can say that, but they still build them badly. when you see sealant being applied sloppily, panels badly fitted, rivets in the wrong place, then you know that it's been built by monkeys who take no pride in their work. I say build a good defender, and it'll be good, but there are certainly things that could change - handbrake not sticking in to my leg, and a bit of elbow room would be nice :)
 
Do defender type vehicles have an exemption from safety requirements

New cars look like they do because they have to comply with safety standards, the doors are thick because of the side impact protection, bumpers are set at a height so most cars hit at the same level

Would they even be allowed to redesign it without covering it in airbags
 
Do defender type vehicles have an exemption from safety requirements

New cars look like they do because they have to comply with safety standards, the doors are thick because of the side impact protection, bumpers are set at a height so most cars hit at the same level

Would they even be allowed to redesign it without covering it in airbags

Jeeps and Merc G wagons manage to get through the legislation and be sold. In fact if you take away the fancy trim the G wagon and the defender have a lot in common.
 
I would want them to go back to an engine that was as easy to maintain as the Tdi's rather than continue with these TDCI things which you need to be really clever to fix. I know they are probably nicer to drive and safer for the flowers but I cant fix them!
 
That'll never happen, all engines have to comply with emissions regulations, it's why Peugeot engines are in loads of different manufacturers vehicles, it's too expensive for every manufacturer to have a range of their own engines so they share

I was talking to someone about the new euro 6 truck engine, to comply with 2014 emissions regulations the exhaust gasses get recycled 6 times, Europe is obsessed with emissions

It's a bit of a joke when most of our goods are produced in china where they just do what they want
 
That'll never happen, all engines have to comply with emissions regulations, it's why Peugeot engines are in loads of different manufacturers vehicles, it's too expensive for every manufacturer to have a range of their own engines so they share

I was talking to someone about the new euro 6 truck engine, to comply with 2014 emissions regulations the exhaust gasses get recycled 6 times, Europe is obsessed with emissions

It's a bit of a joke when most of our goods are produced in china where they just do what they want
Yep we have just exported our emissions to China :rolleyes:
 
well i bought a new one .....well a 12 reg 90xs....with 20 miles on the clock - bargain !

and great fun
 
20 miles?? Damn your first big repair bill will be right around the corner!

:D

well i can see a few wty claims already putting right the finish....but who cares.....its a defender..

this one is a keeper - which is why i bought new..
 
Back
Top