which is better

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

which is the best engine and why


  • Total voters
    45
funny you should mention it mate, its such a relief when youre driving the landy and you dont think/know theres anything wrong with it!

im an offroader, so i get about 1 day in 10 where the car is tip top.

ahh, shame :D
 
In my honest opinion i would prefer the 3.5 because there were no issues with head gaskets or overheating before they started messing about with an engine that was designed to run with carbs and then there's the problem with thin walls between the linings which cause problems what with all the re-boring.
 
ok so now try being 10 inches taller and see how you get on with the roof lining and lack of leg room my bruvs got a classic and its just not the deal and the seats are pants really not as comfortable as the ones in my ES not by a long shot

No MoT's im afraid its a blood thing only nothing personal

What a load of tosh
Disco ES (that's a top of the range one, right?!) vs a Classic what?
Not all classics are the same.... Yeah, I'm 6'6" and headroom is really crap...when the seat has been left set after the missus has driven it... then I wake up and press a lil' button by the side of the seat....bingo! the seat adjusts to how I left it last, including going down so m bonce doesn't rub on the headlining...there's room to even wear a top hat....and I don't even need to play around with the mirrors. they move too.
The missus's own Classic doesn't have leccy seats, so they have to be moved manually...what a pain, my bonce rubs on the headlining....so with that one I woke up and fixed the saggy headlining!! ...bingo! now had more headroom!
The weekend bobtailed offroader classic has bucket seats and internal rollcage....that was a bugger, because I should be not just be rubbing m bonce but knocking the fooka off on the rollcage roof bars....
Either I've found those secret seat adjustments, or maybe I'm not 6'6":rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
In my honest opinion i would prefer the 3.5 because there were no issues with head gaskets or overheating before they started messing about with an engine that was designed to run with carbs and then there's the problem with thin walls between the linings which cause problems what with all the re-boring.

well said, totally agree
 
i have a 3.9 hotwire and love it! simple, reliable etc and sounds good too!

No expert on the 3.5 vs 3.9 but if your buying a potentially 15+ yr old engine - you know your not going to get modern day reliability - your also probably hoping it blows up so you have an excuse to rebuild it with some racey parts at a later date so why not go for the 3.9 - ultimatley its more fun telling your mates (and the girls) you drive a 4l v8 rather than a puny 3.5 lol!
 
The one overriding thing with the Rover V8's is the cooling system and the coolant.

Get that right and it's a reliable lump as far as general running goes. You're always going to get component failures, but so far we haven't had any main engine parts fail, but we have fitted better spark plugs and a set of decent leads.

Philip's V8 that he bought last year had horrendous corrosion of the cooling system, the steel pipes for the heater were rusted through, not just one, we had to replace three of them, they were solidly crusted with rust inside.

That means the liner outers are also rusty, so we are expecting liner troubles at some point as the rust will expand and force the liner/block joint apart.

Most folks don't realise what rust can do in the right conditions. We've just replaced some framing on our 4-wheel trailer, the welds that held it on to the main frame had been broken by the rust expanding between the frame and the chassis.

Ours is approaching 60K on the new engine, and it's a nice lump to drive, no water loss, original radiator (148k miles) but we do run genuine LR OAT coolant in it and always have.

LPG doesn't make a lot of difference, except that the Motronic system doesn't adjust foir vapour flow against hard injection by petrol, so there's a bit of faffing about occasionally, but when we need it to pull the big trailer (next two weekends) it is there and always does the job.

I'd like to get the LPG inlet pipes to the manifold/plenum adjusted for length, as at present some are longer than others, but apart from that it's a great tool.

Peter
 
The one overriding thing with the Rover V8's is the cooling system and the coolant.

Get that right and it's a reliable lump as far as general running goes. You're always going to get component failures, but so far we haven't had any main engine parts fail, but we have fitted better spark plugs and a set of decent leads.

Philip's V8 that he bought last year had horrendous corrosion of the cooling system, the steel pipes for the heater were rusted through, not just one, we had to replace three of them, they were solidly crusted with rust inside.

That means the liner outers are also rusty, so we are expecting liner troubles at some point as the rust will expand and force the liner/block joint apart.

Most folks don't realise what rust can do in the right conditions. We've just replaced some framing on our 4-wheel trailer, the welds that held it on to the main frame had been broken by the rust expanding between the frame and the chassis.

Ours is approaching 60K on the new engine, and it's a nice lump to drive, no water loss, original radiator (148k miles) but we do run genuine LR OAT coolant in it and always have.

LPG doesn't make a lot of difference, except that the Motronic system doesn't adjust foir vapour flow against hard injection by petrol, so there's a bit of faffing about occasionally, but when we need it to pull the big trailer (next two weekends) it is there and always does the job.

I'd like to get the LPG inlet pipes to the manifold/plenum adjusted for length, as at present some are longer than others, but apart from that it's a great tool.

Peter

rover v8s are dry linered not wet so liner outer wont be rusty
 
A bit late on this thread and haven't read all.

But I find any V6 (Jag) or v8 (poss v12, like to try that !) a phenomenal machine. Any time over a dull diesel.

(though I find the diesel invention fantastic ! - our German fellas are great engineers)

Got my 3.5 V8 for 16 years now, and I can say the engine has never let me down. It's done everything For me I asked for. This being motorway cruise, tow upto 5T on a trailer or 1.5T on a pallet in the boot. (a bit heavy but no probs, but easy to load with a forklift)

Have no comparison with 3.9 but did not need it upto now. Would expect the same of it, with just a bit more power.
 
ahhh..old thread,never mind...


(but..liners aint down to lpg in my oppion,but poor maintence, running week,over heating due to fecked rad, arsehole who fitted single point lpg without wideband sensor etc..
same if running petrol..MAINTAIN your cooling sytem!MAINTAIN your fueling and spark system..

also why bother 3.9???fit the latest rv8..ie 4 and 4.6...
 
Back
Top