Freelander 1 All Makes LP Pump Fails 5k miles

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
andyfreelandy

andyfreelandy

Well-Known Member
Posts
5,587
Location
Devon
So fitted an All Makes LP pump 5 k miles ago to try to eliminate a cutting out at 4k revs problem. It didn't solve the problem, see my other thread on this, but I left it fitted. Today turned on key, no buzz and no start. Tapped pump with my best panel beating hammer and presto. Ran for 2 mins then failed again. It has done 5,000 miles since fitting new. Shocking.....
 
andyfreelandy said:
So fitted an All Makes LP pump 5 k miles ago to try to eliminate a cutting out at 4k revs problem. It didn't solve the problem, see my other thread on this, but I left it fitted. Today turned on key, no buzz and no start. Tapped pump with my best panel beating hammer and presto. Ran for 2 mins then failed again. It has done 5,000 miles since fitting new. Shocking.....
Click to expand...

I had this sort of thing happen as well. The commutator segments fall off. Rule of thumb - the LP pump should cost £130, not £30!

Warranty claim?

kermit_rr said:
Ok you've got me defeated, what's an LP pump? Low pressure pump?
Click to expand...

Low pressure pump in wheel arch.
 
So revisiting this now that all is working. At the moment anyway!! Have contacted JGS 4x4 to ask for comments on the failure. I understand it was a low cost pump and fully support the Pierburg route but it is not fit for purpose at any price!! Watch this space for reply.
 
Not looking good so far. Standard 'over a year' response. No interest yet in finding out why it failed so quickly. I have invited them to do so.
 
andyfreelandy said:
Not looking good so far. Standard 'over a year' response. No interest yet in finding out why it failed so quickly. I have invited them to do so.
Click to expand...
If it’s out of warranty you’re in the complex realm of ‘fit for purpose’ and suchlike. Then they can come back with ‘was it fitted by a qualified mechanical engineer?’ and other weaselling.

If you’re not planning on that route, get a pipe cutter/hacksaw and open it up. Piccies would be nice!
 
No reply after inviting JGS if they would like to try to investigate these not fit for purpose pumps. Let's try and stamp on the poor quality items. Cheap yes, but also completely useless. I have reminded JGS that LandyZone are awaiting a reply!!!
 
JGS will just be a reseller of parts. The best they could offer is not to sell that brand of part in the future. Sometime sellers won't do anything unless they see multiple failures. They could have sold 150 and only had one fail. If its out of warranty they wont be able to claim back from their supplier. Harsh on the buyer after a short distance.

Is it marked with a brand like HippoLP?
 
Marked only 14331 and the All Makes box has LR023043 which I guess is the part no. JGS, as you say, cannot help due to warrentee time being up. I am going to take this up with All Makes as they claim same quality as OE. If necessary I will open it up but will speak to them first. If any one else has an All Makes boxed pump that has failed please can you identify the markings on the pump and let me know. Poor quality pumps keep coming up on this site and I, like others, are keen to remove them from the market.
 
I've found the All Makes products are of questionable quality. I've had ball joint boots fail in a few months, on drop links and wishbones. :(
 
All Makes Website....
Quality Replacement Land Rover Parts
Unfortunately, not all replacement parts available today are of the best quality, and it is vitally important to only buy from a company you can trust.

Allmakes have scoured the world to bring you a wide range of quality products at the cheapest possible prices. All have been tested to ensure that the highest quality standards are maintained, and are fully backed by our unconditional twelve month warranty package.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Nardo90
200 TDI engine rebuilt and collected!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (plus back story, short version.)
Replies
14
Views
3K
Nardo90
Nardo90
R
FBH all you need to no info
Replies
7
Views
3K
rhodie
R
The Mad Hat Man
FBH - all you need to know
Replies
2
Views
34K
Echohowl
E
R
fit fix ect FBH
Replies
0
Views
819
rhodie
R
B
TD4 - Difficult to start and cutting out problems
2
Replies
28
Views
13K
john t
john t
Back
Top