300 or V8

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
for road use ide take the 300, but if you want off road v8 has more torque and power wich helps with the steep climbs, but if your going to do alot of water runs 300 would probly be better as they dont have a distributer to worry about.
 
V8 pros
Sound
Sound
Sound
Power
Cons
It's petrol, so your choice of fuel is limited ( yes i know lpg but I think that the duty on this will be rising in the near future)
dissie cap
300tdi pros
bomb proof
run it on any combination of diesel, bio, WVO &SVO
runs almost fully submerged ( bin there done that)
cons
not so powerful as the V8
sounds like a tractor
 
V8 pros
yes i know lpg but I think that the duty on this will be rising in the near future)

The duty difference between LPG and petrol is suppose to be capped for the next 3 years.

One thing to bear in mind is LPG needs the ignition in top-notch form so might be less tolerant in water.

Another thing the 300Tdi seems to more durable than the V8, which has a fairly hard life lugging a disco around, they can be getting pretty tired at around 100k. Saying that your 188k 300Tdi could be starting to develop problems, such as worn turbo etc.

I'd go for the diesel myself, they are quite cheap to run, you can drown 'em and they are simple to fix. They use very little fuel when your offroading them too, I've never used much more than a gallon or so at pay and play days.
 
Down here in Australia, the V8 Disco's are worth peanuts and the diesels fetch premium dollar. The 200 & 300 diesels are bloody tough engines and have proven themselves in our various environments. The V8's here haven't stood up anywhere near as well, and are often clapped-out now.

There are many things I love about owning a diesel...for starters there's the tractor-sound! I realise things are different over your way, but here driving a diesel means you're driving a rig for real use, not for dumping the kiddies off at school. A proper mans-toy. :p

It's not a fast engine, but it's got enough grunt to keep pace with traffic. It will happily sit cruising at 110klm/hr all day long with a full load in the back. You can feel that it's solid and has shed-loads of torque capable of pulling anything. Economy is absolutely brilliant, and I average 1100klm per tank.

The simplicity and design of the engine makes it very easy to work on, with clear access to all areas. It's an very reliable unit which is capable of extremely high mileage so long as maintenance is kept on top of. If you wish to do water crossings and the like, diesel is the way to go due to no dizzy. You will find that maintaining speed on hilly sections of highways can be slower going, but you'd quickly learn what gears and ways to keep the momentum. It's actually quite fun and keeps you more switched-on while driving tbh...and that can't be a bad thing! :)

As a side note about the V8 on lpg, it's been a common conversion down here with mixed reactions. On one hand you either saccrifice your touring range or your tailgate space. On the other, there are frequent reports of backfiring causing numerous problems. I'm not saying this is always the case, and there are some great example V8's out there.

Personally, buy the diesel! :D
 
Thanks for all of the responses, very much appreciated. I have yet to purchase the vehicle but based on the information I have gathered, a diesel it shall be, hopefully a 300 but may have to resort to a 200 depending on finances.

Cheers
cbrr3
 
Hi.....i have had both 200 and 300 TDi and loved them both. Had a 300 auto which was just sooo usefull off road. Very usable configuration for crawling and as long as the turbo is singing, absolutely no probs climbing anything you fancy and great in the wet stuff.

I have just changed back to discovery's after a long spell with p38's and classics.......great to back with the discovery's....don't know why i bought the 38 having bought this d2 to be honest....did have wig wag headlights though (ex Police car) which was much fun!!
 
Back
Top