Freelander 1 Drive Shaft changed again three Amigos

mbrokof · Feb 5, 2022

Morning All,

so here it goes. On Wednesday the right, front drive shaft was changed, Yesterday went to the motorway
switched on cruise control and again the three amigos turned on just like when the left side was changed some weeks ago. I am wondering if it's again the ABS sensor as it was on the other side, but yesterday, when driving back, leaving a car park it was like the breaks were pressed a short moment and then it was driving like normal again. Saw some meters after that the handbreaklight was on, checked the handbrake, but it wasn't applied. It drove sluggish after that and the speed didn't work anymore. After some miles I went to a fuel station and applied the handbrake again, when I started the engine after it all was good again. No three amigos, no handbrake light and it drove like normal since.

I am wondering if it's again the ABS sensor wiring or wheelspeed sensor this time, but it's strange that it happened now again. Will get it read out during the week. Any thoughts about same symptoms?

KR
Matthias

Nodge68 · Feb 5, 2022

Sounds like a data bus issue.

GrumpyGel · Feb 5, 2022

As it has CC it presumably is an automatic.

mbrokof said:
but yesterday, when driving back, leaving a car park it was like the breaks were pressed a short moment and then it was driving like normal again.

So did the revs go up but the car not drive as expected, or did the revs not go up?

Handbrake light can also mean low brake fluid I believe.

mbrokof · Feb 5, 2022

GrumpyGel said:
As it has CC it presumably is an automatic.

Yes, sorry forgot to mention, GG. It is an 02 autobox.
No the revs didn't go up. It accelerated very slowly.
@Nodge68, thanks will have a look into that.

GrumpyGel · Feb 5, 2022

mbrokof said:
Yes, sorry forgot to mention, GG. It is an 02 autobox.
No the revs didn't go up. It accelerated very slowly.
@Nodge68, thanks will have a look into that.

If the revs didn't go up, then the brakes weren't binding.

The ECU would not have been telling the injectors to inject more fuel - either because it didn't pick up the accelerator movement (probably least likely), a/some sensors were telling it to protect the engine (eg fuel pressure) or (as Nodge says) there was corruption in data getting to the ECU or interference on to the injectors (not likely as there's 4 routes).

Looks like you need some diagnostics.

mbrokof · Feb 6, 2022

GrumpyGel said:
If the revs didn't go up, then the brakes weren't binding.

The ECU would not have been telling the injectors to inject more fuel - either because it didn't pick up the accelerator movement (probably least likely), a/some sensors were telling it to protect the engine (eg fuel pressure) or (as Nodge says) there was corruption in data getting to the ECU or interference on to the injectors (not likely as there's 4 routes).

Looks like you need some diagnostics.

Yes, agreed. Got hold of one. Here are some pics from it:
P1605 I read that that should be deleted to see if it returns which I've done.
C1019
C1067
The first three are about those codes and the MAF, the rest I attached as there might be some thoughts on it. Not sure how reliable
those readings are.
It reports back MAF malfunction 0100 as well.

rob_bell · Feb 7, 2022

How many of these faults were historical? Might be worth clearing and seeing what comes back. But it looks as though you've lost both front wheel ABS signals?

mbrokof · Feb 8, 2022

rob_bell said:
How many of these faults were historical? Might be worth clearing and seeing what comes back. But it looks as though you've lost both front wheel ABS signals?

Hi Rob, went to a garage yesterday and got it read out and on his one it showed that all except the MAF and Vehicle Road Speed Signal were historical. He kicked them out to see what of it comes back. The MAF and the other one weren't shown on his one so will wait and see. Thanks.

rob_bell · Feb 9, 2022

Fingers crossed!

mbrokof · Feb 16, 2022

rob_bell said:
Fingers crossed!

Unfortunately not, they are back including the handbrake light now. Will get it read out and see what it says.

rob_bell · Feb 19, 2022

That’s you’re best bet. In mine, I’ve had to replace both front wheel speed sensors, the NSF reluctor ring and the yaw sensor! Oh, and the brake switch. Everything appears to be behaving now though.

tbh had I not have a diagnostic tool, finding the problems would have been neigh on impossible - especially from the start…

mbrokof · Feb 20, 2022

Oh, good. Hope I'll get that sorted soon as well to tackle other bits.
The new fault codes are C1116 Supply Voltage too low (Vehicle Running) and C1067 Right Rear Wheel Speed Sensor Signal Missing Or Too Low on ABS read.
On SRS read it is: Warning Lamp FAilure (Short To Ground Or Open Circuit) and Battery Voltage Too Low => Checked that and came up with 12.71V when off and 14.2 when running and headlamps and fan on three on for a while then 14.19V.
MAF a mentioned above is still one as well.

rob_bell · Feb 21, 2022

I doubt that the low voltage would cause a three amigo fault, unless from the TC/ABS ECU.
The fault sounds as though it is that rear ABS speed sensor… which at least ought to be relatively easy to sort out…

mbrokof · Feb 22, 2022

rob_bell said:
I doubt that the low voltage would cause a three amigo fault, unless from the TC/ABS ECU.
The fault sounds as though it is that rear ABS speed sensor… which at least ought to be relatively easy to sort out…

Yes, I agree. Will get it fixed as MOT is also due next week.

Found three amigos in the park while walking the dog which I would prefer over the LR ones

:

WhatsApp Image 2022-02-20 at 08.49.28.jpeg

mbrokof · Feb 22, 2022

Went to the garage today to get it read out and a complete mess came out. All four sensors were shown on his reader incl. the two above. He deleted everything to see if they would come. One couldn't be cleared, but was for front left and showed historic on his reader, though he had all cleared last time. Not sure if his reader was that good or the one I have at the moment didn't pick up properly. They'll check on live data he said, once in.

rob_bell · Feb 22, 2022

If you can get live data telemetry, that can be really helpful to work out more complex problems

mbrokof · Feb 25, 2022

rob_bell said:
If you can get live data telemetry, that can be really helpful to work out more complex problems

Hope so that they'll find the issue. Even with the three amigos it went through MOT today, no problems.

rob_bell · Feb 26, 2022

You’re lucky - the three amigos are usually an MOT failure

mbrokof · Feb 27, 2022

Yes, was surprised, but hoping it would go through. Am not in when due next week, so thought to go for it on Friday.

mbrokof · Mar 3, 2022

So here comes the joke. The same one that was rewired just some weeks ago was the fault as there was no live data coming through. Was changed cost me 200£. If I would have known could have changed myself but wouldn't have thought that it looks like this:

Freelander 1 Drive Shaft changed again three Amigos

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Attachments

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Active Member

Active Member

Attachments

Similar threads