Disco 2 Do I repair or scrap

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.

Ruian

New Member
Posts
5
Location
Northamptonshire
So my beautiful Lagatha has gone to Valhalla. Her clutch has gone (while hubby was driving her...just saying) and on inspection there is a multiple of things that need doing just to pass the MOT- brakes, bushes, welding (she has just had a new prop shaft- the old one just fell off- and drag link and steering track rod). At only 66000 miles I knew that she was tired when I bought her as she had been left standing for a long time without any TLC but am devastated nonetheless...the engine is willing the body is weak. So the question is...do I shell out the small fortune and get her back on the road or do I sell her for her parts to be donated to a higher cause. My husband wants to simply scrap her:mad:..so needless to say we are not talking at the moment!!!!I I don't have the space to repair her myself (when I say myself I mean mostly my husband). Any advice would be appreciated. I will take photos....I have been told you all like photos
 
In the end this will be down to how much money you are prepared to spend on her.
66K is nothing on a disco 2 so I am even surprised all the bushes etc have gone. Brakes aren't expensive to do and should eb easy enough even in the road.
If you have listed ALL that needs doing it doesn't actually sound that bad. The most challenging m,ay be the welding.
How decent is your MOT tester? Some will give you an honest one and some, apparently there are those around who hate LRs and their owners, who will try to consign your love to the waste bin.
But I'd be tempted to take it for a test and get the failure sheet so they have to put your money where their mouths are, then you'll have a better idea of what actually really is bad enough to fail.
Then you can have another think about it.
I had to have my rear chassis extensively patched this year and it only cost £200 even including taking the the fuel tank off and putting it back on.
The rest can be regarded as simply consumables which would go eventually anyway.
Best of luck!:)
(But I would keep it. Ones at that mileage in good nick are going for a fortune!)
 
Don’t be fooled by low mileage, I’ve seen shagged out land rovers at 50k and good ones at 200k
 
I'd go for repair. If you sell (scrap or spares) then you have to buy another, which might be as bad or worse than the one you have. Better the (low mileage) devil you know, that's my 2 pennorth.
Not saying you are wrong as this is possible with any make of vehicle, but it will take a little time to see how sh@gged the engine and driveline are.
Compression and leak-down tests would be a point of departure.
 
Its a tough call to make, if funds allow & if yous have the skills/tools/time to repair then id repair it
66k is a low for a D2 but they can be money pits. No point throwing loads of cash at it if its a right
dog cut your losses & look for a nicer one there are plenty of them.
I looked at a 56k D2 not too long ago stunning black not a blemish outside its probably the worst one id
seen underneath & that was laid up for a few years.

It needs a landy guy to look at it & sum up the costs to repair.
Sometimes hard to judge the true condition from pictures.
The reg number might be more helpful to check the mot history,
 
Its a tough call to make, if funds allow & if yous have the skills/tools/time to repair then id repair it
66k is a low for a D2 but they can be money pits. No point throwing loads of cash at it if its a right
dog cut your losses & look for a nicer one there are plenty of them.
I looked at a 56k D2 not too long ago stunning black not a blemish outside its probably the worst one id
seen underneath & that was laid up for a few years.

It needs a landy guy to look at it & sum up the costs to repair.
Sometimes hard to judge the true condition from pictures.
The reg number might be more helpful to check the mot history,
If you can't be bothered to go look at a landy with a torch, overalls and a prodder, like a blunt screwdriver AND be prepared to get underneath no matter what the weather and the location of the puddles, then you will get what you deserve. Harsh, but true!
It can be quite fun handing the owner large pieces of rusty metal that fall off while you are having a good look!
(Well I found it funny, he didn't!)
 
If you can't be bothered to go look at a landy with a torch, overalls and a prodder, like a blunt screwdriver AND be prepared to get underneath no matter what the weather and the location of the puddles, then you will get what you deserve. Harsh, but true!
It can be quite fun handing the owner large pieces of rusty metal that fall off while you are having a good look!
(Well I found it funny, he didn't!)

Savage :D:D
 
Age as well as mileage need to be factored in. Rubber seals wear with use and get brittle over time. Some parts will still age even if mileage is low.

It is true we like pic's. In particular pic's of rust. If you can catch the right angle to see straight through a rust hole yer get bonus points. A dramatic shot of the moon preferred or just yer foot will do.

When adding up repair costs its best to consider how long it will repair the vehicle for, and what may be on the horizon needing to be done in a year or two also. The obvious result being it will cost more to repair than buying a reliable Freelander 1 or 2. If you can afford the repairs and they will give you another say 4 years of disco motoring then I personally would consider that to be on a par with paying to have yer legs broken. But its a way of splitting the cost over a number if years to see what yer gain from the investment.

As a seasoned Freelander owner I can appreciate the feeling of joy to own yer own vehicle and will have become quite fond of it. So I can understand the emotional tie to want to keep it and repair it. Could you convince yer husband to do some if the work and the garage does the big jobs? Offer to buy him some more tools?

All vehicles need wear and tear repairs as they age. Have you spent a lot on it already? If so you would lose that money if you scrap it now. Continue to gain from previous repairs if you keep. I assume yer only do a low mileage so that reduces mechanical repairs as it will have less use and not be so eggspensive to maintain as other disco's in the future.

If yer struggling then get an mot done as suggested above by others. Its don't have to be official and registered. It's a cheap way if knowing what needs done now and what could be on the horizon. Knowing this will help advise the cost now and potentially in say 2 years time.

I had the same agonising problem with my Freelander 1. I'd spent over 7,000 sovs over the years keeping it going with repairs and servicing. That included an auto gearbox replaced by a garage. After that i cut costs by doing the work myself where I can. A lot of the faults were damage from taking it oft road for fun. Like oil seals failing. Yer won't get back the cost of previous repairs if yer sell it now. You will if yer keep it. The emotional tie is a big factor. You could look at rust proofing and other preventative measures to ensure it survives the future.

I wanted to keep my Freelander 1 as emotional tie's took over and I couldn't sell it. So I took it all apart and rebuilt it with newer parts from the Freelander 2 catalogue. So I still have my old adorable Freelander 1, but he now looks like a Freelander 2, with many more years of motoring ahead of us. Just like rebuilding an ole tratter but no welding was involved.
 
Age as well as mileage need to be factored in. Rubber seals wear with use and get brittle over time. Some parts will still age even if mileage is low.

It is true we like pic's. In particular pic's of rust. If you can catch the right angle to see straight through a rust hole yer get bonus points. A dramatic shot of the moon preferred or just yer foot will do.

When adding up repair costs its best to consider how long it will repair the vehicle for, and what may be on the horizon needing to be done in a year or two also. The obvious result being it will cost more to repair than buying a reliable Freelander 1 or 2. If you can afford the repairs and they will give you another say 4 years of disco motoring then I personally would consider that to be on a par with paying to have yer legs broken. But its a way of splitting the cost over a number if years to see what yer gain from the investment.

As a seasoned Freelander owner I can appreciate the feeling of joy to own yer own vehicle and will have become quite fond of it. So I can understand the emotional tie to want to keep it and repair it. Could you convince yer husband to do some if the work and the garage does the big jobs? Offer to buy him some more tools?

All vehicles need wear and tear repairs as they age. Have you spent a lot on it already? If so you would lose that money if you scrap it now. Continue to gain from previous repairs if you keep. I assume yer only do a low mileage so that reduces mechanical repairs as it will have less use and not be so eggspensive to maintain as other disco's in the future.

If yer struggling then get an mot done as suggested above by others. Its don't have to be official and registered. It's a cheap way if knowing what needs done now and what could be on the horizon. Knowing this will help advise the cost now and potentially in say 2 years time.

I had the same agonising problem with my Freelander 1. I'd spent over 7,000 sovs over the years keeping it going with repairs and servicing. That included an auto gearbox replaced by a garage. After that i cut costs by doing the work myself where I can. A lot of the faults were damage from taking it oft road for fun. Like oil seals failing. Yer won't get back the cost of previous repairs if yer sell it now. You will if yer keep it. The emotional tie is a big factor. You could look at rust proofing and other preventative measures to ensure it survives the future.

I wanted to keep my Freelander 1 as emotional tie's took over and I couldn't sell it. So I took it all apart and rebuilt it with newer parts from the Freelander 2 catalogue. So I still have my old adorable Freelander 1, but he now looks like a Freelander 2, with many more years of motoring ahead of us. Just like rebuilding an ole tratter but no welding was involved.
Despite the fact this thread seems to have wobbled off into Freeloader territory, I agree totally with the sentiments and the thoughts behind them. The whole point of running your vehicle for ages is to defeat depreciation. And you only do this by keeping it and maintaining it. £7000 is nothing if depraciation is offset.

I have never bought a new car for that very reason and have maintained them myself from the very beginning, i.e. 17 years old, slowly learning more and more, acquiring more tools and skills as time went on. I have saved thousands this way and also had the pleasure of knowing my car is reliable and safe.:):):)
 
An alternative to scrapping would be to sell it for spares or repair. Salvage dealers currently aren't offering much for scrapers. My rule of thumb is when a car starts costing more than £500 per year to repair (not counting consumables like tyres, brakes etc) then it's time to get rid. Of course, I don't apply this rule to my beloved series, which incidentally' doesn't cost much at all.

Col
 
An alternative to scrapping would be to sell it for spares or repair. Salvage dealers currently aren't offering much for scrapers. My rule of thumb is when a car starts costing more than £500 per year to repair (not counting consumables like tyres, brakes etc) then it's time to get rid. Of course, I don't apply this rule to my beloved series, which incidentally' doesn't cost much at all.

Col
Talking of love for Landies, wasn't it Shakespeare who said "Love is a money spending thing"?
 
with 66 on the clock it worth repairing, even if it costs you £3000, where are you going to get another vehicle for that price that could last you another 10+++ years
 
Many thanks all for your replies and sorry for the tardy response, I have been offline for a few days. I think after weighing everything up I am going to let her go...sob sob. I don't have the funds to keep her going. The engine is good but the chassis is more like a colander. Before I had her we think (going on MOT records) she was left standing for a while, possibly in water, and the rust is everywhere. I just don't have the time to give her the love and attention she needs. She needs a new clutch (as said before) but it is the sheer amount of welding that needs to be done and I don't have the skills/ money at the moment. I am hoping she can be used as a donor car so will try and sell her. I am heartbroken. I have another car at the moment and think I will save my pennies and look to get another one in the future. I didn't imagine I would be this emotionally attached to a car. If I had a big enough garage or somewhere to store her I might have kept her and loving fixed her bit by bit. Again thank you for all your response it is VERY MUCH appreciated. I will try and post some pictures in the next day so you understand why I have come to this decision...sob sob.
 
Back
Top