Landy Boy1
New Member
- Posts
- 131
- Location
- Scotland
Hi!
Well basically, my old faithful Citroén Xantia 2.0's head gasket blew and ruined the whole engine, so I need a replacement car!
However I can't decide between the mighty 3.5 V8 Petrol guzzler or the 2.5 S4 Diesel engine...
And to make the decision even more hard, there is a 1989 Land Rover Discovery 200 TDI and a 1993 Land Rover Discovery 3.5 V8 for sale in my local paper and both are open to offers!
Here is the pros and cons list I have got already:
200 TDI PROS:
Economical - More Reliable - Easier To Maintain - Known To Last Over 300,000 Miles.
200 TDI CONS:
Extremely Slow - Turbos Sometimes Go Bad.
3.5 V8 PROS:
Very Powerful - Higher Top Speed - Easier To Start In Winter (important as winter is coming up fast!)
3.5 V8 CONS:
Will Barely Get 20MPG - Requires More Maintainence To Keep Running Well.
So, what should I go for!?
Here are the list of details for the two Landys for sale:
1993 Land Rover Discovery 200 2.5 TDI
112,000 Miles
1 Month MOT
3 Month TAX
Manual Gear Box
Serviced Last Week
4 New Tyres
£995 ONO
1990 Land Rover Discovery 3.5 V8
266,000 Miles
No MOT
8 Month TAX
Automatic Gear Box
Requires Quite A Lot For MOT
£150 ONO
Quite a price difference eh! But what one should I go for!? I can do the work for the MOT myself, and have spoken to the guy and it is mainly tyres and stuff, so nothing like engine mounts or corrosion, but I basically need to know if I should go for the Diesel or the Petrol!
Both of them have a bit of wheel arch rust etc... but structurally they are both 100% fine!
I won't be using the car for off-roading, just driving on roads! So I don't need one that I can convert to a monster truck!
Please reply! Both owners need a quick sale and if I come to a decision tonight I'll get the money out the bank and hopefully buy the one I want tomorrow morning!
So, it is in your hands! Petrol BHP or Diesel Torque!?
Quoting Carroll Shelby - "Horse Power sells the car, Torque wins the race!"
Though in this case I don't think either will win any races! :lol:
Well basically, my old faithful Citroén Xantia 2.0's head gasket blew and ruined the whole engine, so I need a replacement car!
However I can't decide between the mighty 3.5 V8 Petrol guzzler or the 2.5 S4 Diesel engine...
And to make the decision even more hard, there is a 1989 Land Rover Discovery 200 TDI and a 1993 Land Rover Discovery 3.5 V8 for sale in my local paper and both are open to offers!
Here is the pros and cons list I have got already:
200 TDI PROS:
Economical - More Reliable - Easier To Maintain - Known To Last Over 300,000 Miles.
200 TDI CONS:
Extremely Slow - Turbos Sometimes Go Bad.
3.5 V8 PROS:
Very Powerful - Higher Top Speed - Easier To Start In Winter (important as winter is coming up fast!)
3.5 V8 CONS:
Will Barely Get 20MPG - Requires More Maintainence To Keep Running Well.
So, what should I go for!?
Here are the list of details for the two Landys for sale:
1993 Land Rover Discovery 200 2.5 TDI
112,000 Miles
1 Month MOT
3 Month TAX
Manual Gear Box
Serviced Last Week
4 New Tyres
£995 ONO
1990 Land Rover Discovery 3.5 V8
266,000 Miles
No MOT
8 Month TAX
Automatic Gear Box
Requires Quite A Lot For MOT
£150 ONO
Quite a price difference eh! But what one should I go for!? I can do the work for the MOT myself, and have spoken to the guy and it is mainly tyres and stuff, so nothing like engine mounts or corrosion, but I basically need to know if I should go for the Diesel or the Petrol!
Both of them have a bit of wheel arch rust etc... but structurally they are both 100% fine!
I won't be using the car for off-roading, just driving on roads! So I don't need one that I can convert to a monster truck!
Please reply! Both owners need a quick sale and if I come to a decision tonight I'll get the money out the bank and hopefully buy the one I want tomorrow morning!
So, it is in your hands! Petrol BHP or Diesel Torque!?
Quoting Carroll Shelby - "Horse Power sells the car, Torque wins the race!"
Though in this case I don't think either will win any races! :lol:
Last edited: