Air to Springs

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
Yet more rubbish statements about cause & effect from you eh ?
All I said was 'I did this and another thing went away'. I wasn't quoting rubbish, I was explaining my recent experience with my P38. It's not my fault you don't like my experience or why you can't explain the link but, it was real and I'm only too pleased it has gone away. You should be aware that the whole point of performing FMEA analysis on a new car, prior to release, is to find unintended consequence when wires get accidentally crossed by damage or corrosion or by some other means and having spent 45 years in the electronics engineering industry, I would suggest that LR didn't do a thorough job with their FMEA analysis, which is why this model has such a bad reputation with the general public. It's true that a previous owner may have messed with the wiring but, more likely there's a latent fault in my P38 that caused the snap, crackle and pop noises. I'll never find the reason without an extensive audit and I don't have enough life in me to start that exercise. The purpose of my recent report was to help other members who may have had a similar problem. Clearly, this has never happened to you and I'm very happy for you but, you're not being forced to reply to my posts, so if you don't like them, don't comment. You can put away your pitch fork now.
 
The clicking is no doubt the result of corroded connectors somewhere and nothing to do with FMEA checks that cannot possibly show the result of 20 years plus of deterioration.
That's not my experience and I disagree. The exact purpose of an FMEA audit is to find unintended connection and when properly performed, the FMEA does not care how that connection happened. Obviously, an FMEA is not perfect an relies upon imperfect humans to perform the FMEA but, if thoroughly performed, an FMEA will find every fault. Note: this is one reason why very few planes fall from the sky and why planes are very expensive to manufacture - compared to cars. Anyway, this has been an experience but, I've had enough. Bye.
 
That's not my experience and I disagree. The exact purpose of an FMEA audit is to find unintended connection and when properly performed, the FMEA does not care how that connection happened. Obviously, an FMEA is not perfect an relies upon imperfect humans to perform the FMEA but, if thoroughly performed, an FMEA will find every fault. Note: this is one reason why very few planes fall from the sky and why planes are very expensive to manufacture - compared to cars. Anyway, this has been an experience but, I've had enough. Bye.
Aircraft use quality connectors not the crap tin plate connectors used on P38's. Look at LZ over time and corroded connector's crop up time and again. JLR and their predecessors are only interested in the vehicle surviving for 3 to 5 years what happens after that is of no consequence. Some makers use gold plated contacts on critical connectors as it the case with my Toyota.
Easier to blame the EAS and inadequate testing than fix the fault. If you disconnected the head unit and you car has distributed amps, leaving the amp input open will not help matters.
 
Mine's never clicked in nearly ten years my mate. She's been stuck in water upto her bcem, had the usual leaks and had the connectors removed after a few years of ownership. My sons had some radio noise but all down to the corrosion in the left footwell connectors and once removed. Bingo. 👍
 
Last edited:
That's not my experience and I disagree. The exact purpose of an FMEA audit is to find unintended connection and when properly performed, the FMEA does not care how that connection happened. Obviously, an FMEA is not perfect an relies upon imperfect humans to perform the FMEA but, if thoroughly performed, an FMEA will find every fault. Note: this is one reason why very few planes fall from the sky and why planes are very expensive to manufacture - compared to cars. Anyway, this has been an experience but, I've had enough. Bye.
Economic fabrication I call it and in the aircraft zone and quoted by an engineer I spoke to in the aircraft or airliner game, they call it value fabrication.
It's a question of money and budget as with everything. Although in comparison a vehicle may Injure or kill a handful of people were as a plane will kill 300+.. Sad to say we are playing a numbers game🤯.

Don't get upset, we all have opinions, we can air them and leave it their.
If your car for you is a better place to be after doing the work thats good for you. I'm happy your happy.
I'm on air and somtimes id love to rip the bloody system out for its stupidity but I do love the convenience of it.
You do yours lad and I'll do mine😎👍
 
Last edited:
Aircraft use quality connectors not the crap tin plate connectors used on P38's. Look at LZ over time and corroded connector's crop up time and again. JLR and their predecessors are only interested in the vehicle surviving for 3 to 5 years what happens after that is of no consequence. Some makers use gold plated contacts on critical connectors as it the case with my Toyota.
Easier to blame the EAS and inadequate testing than fix the fault. If you disconnected the head unit and you car has distributed amps, leaving the amp input open will not help matters.
Absolutely correct. There are loads of electrical noise sources in cars, hence why the HK Audio uses balanced audio connections & have each amplifier grounded. Most likely that car has corroded connectors in the footwells . . . where the balanced audio flows & it's randomly unbalanced !! As I said if the amps are still active with the head unit disconnected, then somebody has bodged it !!
 
Back
Top