Hi thanks for the reply - just to confirm exactly what you mean by making sure they don’t try and turn it over? You mean that they don’t start the engine? Asking because some other advice is to listen to the engine to locate the noise. Apologies if I’m being stupid! Just thought it best to check
Help! D4 SDV6 clacking noise
- Thread starter Chris LR
- Start date
This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
Do as suggested and remove and cut open the oil filter, if it has bits in then there is no need to go any further.
- Posts
- 47,170
- Location
- East Dorset
I have just contacted my neighbour but only just remembered that he is on here anyway, don't know if he reads his notifications as his English isn't great.
Can't remember his handle, but he tried to help a bloke quite a bit to the north of us, even posted him his Nanocom for him to use, which to me seems very generous to risk! I don't know if his nanocom is unlocked for SDv6.
Hopefully he'll come on as i sent him a link to this thread.
- Posts
- 47,170
- Location
- East Dorset
- Posts
- 36,805
- Location
- North Shropshire
Last online in October
- Posts
- 47,170
- Location
- East Dorset
As I can see his LRs from my patio, and spoke to him just a coupla days ago, I know he is up to his neck in stuff!!!
I doubt he does go on LZ much as his Eengleesh ain't brill, but I emailed him so he may pop on anyway!
- Posts
- 47,170
- Location
- East Dorset
Alain has just emailed me, he has some severe personal problems but he took the time to tell me this.
He just had an engine rebuilt by a guy who has appaz a very high reputation but 4000 kms later it has seized, also the garagey bloke said that he isn't touching 3 litre V6s any more. So sadly it doesn't look as if he knows anyone he can recommend at the moment.
Here is part of what he said, it makes grim reading.
"Mais, pour un rendez-vous pris en juin pour septembre, il a attaqué le véhicule en février. Après presque 7000€, 4000km plus tard , moteur à nouveau cassé. On ne sais pas encore pourquoi, mais presque plus d'huile moteur, perte de liquide de refroidissement. Je pense moteur serré, bloqué. Alors je peux difficilement le recommander. "
At least your moteur is not bloqué.
Very best of luck mate.
He just had an engine rebuilt by a guy who has appaz a very high reputation but 4000 kms later it has seized, also the garagey bloke said that he isn't touching 3 litre V6s any more. So sadly it doesn't look as if he knows anyone he can recommend at the moment.
Here is part of what he said, it makes grim reading.
"Mais, pour un rendez-vous pris en juin pour septembre, il a attaqué le véhicule en février. Après presque 7000€, 4000km plus tard , moteur à nouveau cassé. On ne sais pas encore pourquoi, mais presque plus d'huile moteur, perte de liquide de refroidissement. Je pense moteur serré, bloqué. Alors je peux difficilement le recommander. "
At least your moteur is not bloqué.
Very best of luck mate.
Fantastic, thank you very much indeed
Eeesh. €7k down the drain!
Quick update for the folks who were kind enough to lend me their advice a few weeks ago.
Just heard from JLR. Email said “we’ve noticed a knocking from the engine… and here’s a quote of €1300 to take the diff off and remove the sump to inspect it”
2 weeks it’s been with them
Just heard from JLR. Email said “we’ve noticed a knocking from the engine… and here’s a quote of €1300 to take the diff off and remove the sump to inspect it”
2 weeks it’s been with them
- Posts
- 36,805
- Location
- North Shropshire
You took it in to the garage with a knocking noise and they've turned round and told you they've diagnosed a knocking noise!?Quick update for the folks who were kind enough to lend me their advice a few weeks ago.
Just heard from JLR. Email said “we’ve noticed a knocking from the engine… and here’s a quote of €1300 to take the diff off and remove the sump to inspect it”
2 weeks it’s been with them
Maybe they should earn their money, get a stethoscope or and see if it's coming from the top/bottom/front/back
- Posts
- 36,805
- Location
- North Shropshire
What did they say was wrong? That's a stupid price for a brand new engine! You need to be talking to a specialist about a second hand engine. In my opinion, assuming they have diagnosed correctly
I haven’t got the details yet, but said it was damaged beyond repair.
I’m told that £12k for an engine (just the part) from JLR is the going rate, so unfortunately I’m not surprised.
I’m doing all this in my second language which makes it harder and my search for LR specialists near us has been fruitless. Another forum member knows a local who had the same issue, did his homework, went to a specialist and had it fail after 7k. Back to square one.
Not sure what other options I have
