M

MCreed

New Member
icon9.gif
Re: Thud when reversing
Hi all, just thought I'd post an update on my "thud" problem... so far the car has been in the garage for the past three weeks - :mad: Personally, I think that the mechanic is being a bit of a git but there's nothing I can do until he fixes it. What started off as a thud when reversing with the wheel locked, turned into a grating noise while driving, so I dropped it straight to the garage informing the mechanic that it was "probably the prop shaft bolts or the rear bushes" (he looked like he'd just seen a flying pig - I mean, how could a woman possibly even know what these terms meant, let alone pose a theory on what might be wrong underneath a car... ;) ). That will be three weeks ago next Friday. He's telling me some bushes were gone (probably just to make me feel better) but now he's saying that the transfer box is gone. I can't understand how he can tell that when he hasn't even taken it out to check yet. Anyhow, bottom line is he gave me a price of 2,500.00 euro to have it fixed - that was with a new part costing 2,000 euro and labour costing 500. He told me that under no circumstances could a reconditioned part be put in as it would just go again. Anyhow, in spite of him, I've found a reconditioned part and given it to him to put in - part cost me 700 euro. That was given to him last Friday, and it's still not in!!! He's telling me I should have the car back on Wed, and then I need to get rid of it as fast as possible as this transfer box will only go again????? I am gutted as I love my Freelander, even though I've spent a fortune on bits so far. Is it possible that I've just bought a lemon and it's better to cut my losses at this stage?? Anyone any thoughts on this whole transfer box saga??? :confused: I think that when a mechanic sees a woman standing in the forecourt, they just make up any old rubbish to make her go away.
 
Now I am no expert (No **** I hear you all cry) but going by the discriptions I have heard from mates with Hippo's where the IRD has gone they do not drive at all. Lots of crunchy tinkly noises and the feeling of cogs being stripped of their teeth.
 
If you are thinkin "Saw ya comming" then yeah, quite possibly. If you are also thinking "get a second opinion" then yeah - I am thinkin what you are thinkin.:(
 
Hi all, (this is starting to resemble "Dear Diary"...) :) Just got off the phone from the 'mechanic'... who informs me that my car is ready to be collected. Apparently the transfer box 'did the job' and it's now driving perfectly again. Mind you, he's also telling me that because I sourced a reconditioned part (for 700 euro as opposed to 2000 for a new one) - I must get rid of the car asap as the reconditioned part will give up the ghost in a few months. Could someone explain that logic to me please because it doesn't make sense to me! Also, he reckons that the fact that the head gasket was replaced about 8 months ago, that it will go again, and next time I'll need a new engine. :eek: Anyway, bottom line is that he's insisting that I'm going to haemorrhage money in the long run if I keep the car. I LOVE MY CAR!!!!! Mind you, he still hasn't given me a final figure for the labour cost of installing the part.

I think I'll enrol in a car maintenance course in the autumn!! ;)
 
MCreed said:
Also, he reckons that the fact that the head gasket was replaced about 8 months ago, that it will go again, and next time I'll need a new engine. :eek:
Click to expand...

I can see me being flamed by Ming etc here - but here goes. I have had head gasket probs on my V6 Freebie and both the local LR Dealer and a LR Rally preparer have stated that "because of liner problems - they will only replace engines, not fix head gaskets". Pretty poor show if yu ask me, but it seems to be common place. Not knowing your engine type, it's difficult to comment further, but (sorry guys) some of the engines used on the Freelanders do appear to be prone to HG failure.:eek:
 
MCreed said:
Hi all, (this is starting to resemble "Dear Diary"...) :) Just got off the phone from the 'mechanic'... who informs me that my car is ready to be collected. Apparently the transfer box 'did the job' and it's now driving perfectly again. I LOVE MY CAR!!!!!

I think I'll enrol in a car maintenance course in the autumn!! ;)
Click to expand...

Way to go girl!;)
Yes! its a car It will break down,
Sounds like your mechanics a right laugh a minute.:rolleyes:

Glad yer back on the road, keep reading the post on here then you'll have a better idea of what to look out for.It aint all doom and gloom!:D
 
Good man Mc creed , good motors, but gota look after em ,otherwise youll end up topin yerself like the floppy hat man. . .:D
 
ming said:
Good man Mc creed , good motors, but gota look after em ,otherwise youll end up topin yerself like the floppy hat man. . .:D
Click to expand...

rofwl ming - good one, but I have to correct u - it's the MAD hat man - I aint just mad - I is livid!:p . The bits that are floppy are........ well, floppy bits;)
r u tryin to tell me my hippo will be OK now?
 
The Mad Hat Man said:
rofwl ming - good one, but I have to correct u - it's the MAD hat man - I aint just mad - I is livid!:p . The bits that are floppy are........ well, floppy bits;)
r u tryin to tell me my hippo will be OK now?
Click to expand...
No but i do feel for ya ,feel like comin down and fixing it for ya, but i'm tied to my quest for planet domination, just stick the modified head gasket on ,and get it going,its not rocket science. . .:rolleyes:
 
The Mad Hat Man said:
- I aint just mad - I is livid!:p . The bits that are floppy are........ well, floppy bits;)
Click to expand...

Aahh! that explaines all the stressed out posts, you tried Viagra supposed to be good for your particular problem:D
come to us all with age :rolleyes: and stress apparently:p
 
mondo said:
Aahh! that explaines all the stressed out posts, you tried Viagra supposed to be good for your particular problem:D
come to us all with age :rolleyes: and stress apparently:p
Click to expand...
Needs a good old whippin i feel. . .:eek:
 
ming said:
Needs a good old whippin i feel. . .:eek:
Click to expand...

I agree, If he carries on ****in whinin on about the ****in lemon he bought :rolleyes:
You'd think any sane person would do a bit o researh BEFORE you buy any sort of motor wunt yer?:rolleyes: :D :p floppy hat or no floppy hat;)
 
mondo said:
I agree, If he carries on ****in whinin on about the ****in lemon he bought :rolleyes:
You'd think any sane person would do a bit o researh BEFORE you buy any sort of motor wunt yer?:rolleyes: :D :p floppy hat or no floppy hat;)
Click to expand...
He's got the whole Ming family upset Mrs Ming is out zappin skodas, Porky's got that upset he's left home. . .:mad:
 
ming said:
He's got the whole Ming family upset Mrs Ming is out zappin skodas, Porky's got that upset he's left home. . .:mad:
Click to expand...

Nahh! dont worry about porky, he'll be back, soon be dinner time;)
 
ming said:
No but i do feel for ya ,feel like comin down and fixing it for ya, but i'm tied to my quest for planet domination, just stick the modified head gasket on ,and get it going,its not rocket science. . .:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Thanks Ming - but even an Intergalactic Lord only has so many powers;)
 
mondo said:
Aahh! that explaines all the stressed out posts, you tried Viagra supposed to be good for your particular problem:D
come to us all with age :rolleyes: and stress apparently:p
Click to expand...

I aint stressed - just tired!;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

A
Replacing Transfer Case (PTU) 2013 Freelander TD4
Replies
2
Views
381
AUMF
A
dave evans
Transfer box
Replies
3
Views
1K
dag019
dag019
Padda.116
D2 Transfer Box exploded?
Replies
11
Views
978
MJI
MJI
O
300 tdi transfer box
Replies
4
Views
426
old chap
O
T
Transfer box output nut torque
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Hicap phill
H