Depends what you want it for......if you want long pulls go for the hydraulic....it'll work all day. Lecky is great but puts a helluva strain on your battery,,,,even with extra batteries and uprated charging if you use it for any length of time the voltage goes down and the amps start piling up and everything starts getting hot

The main advantage of lecky is you can use it when your engine dies in that little puddle that has you wishing you'd brought along your waders.........BUT.....not for long