PD Engine Oil

This site contains affiliate links for which LandyZone may be compensated if you make a purchase.
tom1979

tom1979

Well-Known Member
Full Member
Posts
2,145
Location
East of England, UK
I try and buy oil in bulk (several 20L containers at a time) and will soon need to order some more. I have found this one which specifically states it’s for unit injector engines, something I have never seen before.

Does anyone that’s used this or any other oil stating “for PD or EUI engines” have any feedback about it - is it worth it? Our last “batch” was Exol Optima Vimax 5w40 ACEA A3 B3 B4. API SL/CF. It is comparable in price to the Exol oil we have been using, my only concern being it has a C3 ACEA rating which I would think be more suited to a DPF-equipped vehicle?

COMMA X-FLOW TYPE PD 5W40 - 20 Litre
https://motornuts.co.uk/xfpd20l?uil...MI-8eWta6L3QIVR5nVCh3CrwHuEAQYAiABEgJAk_D_BwE
 
I have used the PD Plus version in my missus car this year, no adverse issues (and I would not expect any). This one appears to be suitable for vehicles with exhaust after treatments (dpf's, cats). Tech data sheets attached for comparison. I am a big fan of Comma oils, for years I have used Halfords brand which are produced by Comma and were sold alongside Comma branded oil for years (but much less evident on Halfords shelf these days). Now I usually buy online and get it delivered for less than it costs in the shop.
 

Attachments

  • 14790.pdf
    357.4 KB · Views: 235
  • 15257.pdf
    333.4 KB · Views: 260
Blimey that’s pretty crappy dude, I’d be pretty upset if I saw that In my sump but there is worse things to be in there I suppose
 
tom1979 said:
What oil are you running in your TD5? I’ve never seen an oil specifically state it’s for EUI engines
Click to expand...
Use only PD/EUI specific oil if you want the best, i've been insisting on this for a while now, it seems since 2014 https://www.landyzone.co.uk/search/39429538/?q=pd+oil&o=relevance&c[user][0]=9153 ...if you have patience to read all those threads you'll find enough arguments against the "old school" thinking or the specs shown in RAVE which in this area became obsolete IMO.... and i'm not gonna have the whole discussion again cos it exhausted me in 4 years :cool:
 
Last edited:
sierrafery said:
Use only PD/EUI specific oil if you want the best, i've been insisting on this for a while now, it seems since 2014 https://www.landyzone.co.uk/search/39429538/?q=pd+oil&o=relevance&c[user][0]=9153 ...if you have patience to read all those threads you'll find enough arguments against the "old school" thinking or the specs shown in RAVE which in this area became obsolete IMO.... and i'm not gonna have the whole discussion again cos it exhausted me in 4 years :cool:
Click to expand...

Are you using the C3 one mentioned above?
 
I have to rectify, i checked in the garage, it's not exactly the same type mine is Comma diesel PD plus 5W40 but it seems the same spec
 
Tom
Go onto YouTube and type in total quartz 10w40, there is a chap on there who tests a load of oils and this one always comes out with great results and cleanliness
 
Discodevon said:
Tom
Go onto YouTube and type in total quartz 10w40, there is a chap on there who tests a load of oils and this one always comes out with great results and cleanliness
Click to expand...

A 10w oil in this country might be a bit thick especially in the winter! I know in the hotter countries like Australia they run 10w (or even thicker). I just wondered if the PD oil would be better as it specifically states its for EUI engines.
 
tom1979 said:
A 10w oil in this country might be a bit thick especially in the winter! I know in the hotter countries like Australia they run 10w (or even thicker). I just wondered if the PD oil would be better as it specifically states its for EUI engines.
Click to expand...
Not sure if it’s too thick but I would imagine a 5w would be better for saving fuel
 
I have asked the technical department at Comma about the PD oil, specifically why it states it is for EUI engines but their own website does not list it for the TD5, and got the following response :


Thank you for your enquiry.

Typically we would not recommend PD Plus for this engine as this offers different performance to what the engine manufacturer specifies- A5/B5. Our causes for concern are:
  1. A5/B5 oils typically offer better fuel economy
  2. A5/B5 oils typically contain more detergency better suited to some engines
However this is not to say PD Plus would not perform well- we just haven’t got the data or experience to confirm this.

Kind regards,
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

lightning
Does the TD5 need a PD engine oil?
Replies
0
Views
904
lightning
lightning
K
Freelander 2 (LR2) Wrong oil?
Replies
3
Views
4K
Nodge68
Nodge68
Renkvkoevorden
engine oil to use with 200 TDi land rover
Replies
2
Views
788
payydg
payydg
lightning
Engine oil question TD5
2 3 4
Replies
62
Views
17K
chris-the-gerbil
C
C
Oil specification
Replies
7
Views
1K
Hippo
Hippo
Back
Top